The Ultimate First Street Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Recipe

I am a member of the Collective Bias™ Social Fabric® Community. This shop has been compensated as part of a social shopper insights study for Collective Bias™ and Smart & Final.

First Street Ultimate Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich #ChooseSmart

Mother’s Day is all about mom’s favorite things, right? And I know that my mom – and mother in law – loves sweets. Since it’s been so warm lately I knew she’d appreciate something cool if she were down here (don’t worry mom, we can make these again!).

So when I headed out to Smart & Final to pick up some ingredients for an awesome dessert to serve on Mother’s Day, I knew that First Street ice cream would be the perfect base for any dish.

I thought bringing my husband along with me as we shopped would be a bad idea but he inspired this dish when he asked if he could pick up some chocolate chip cookies too. Genius!! Why not make ice cream sandwiches?

First Street Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich #ChooseSmart Smart & Final Shop

Lets not just stop there… lets make them the Ultimate Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich! So we grabbed some First Street Cookies and Cream ice cream, First Street chocolate chip cookies, and a bag of mini chocolate chips (but were considering a huge bottle of First Street assorted nonpareils – they just weren’t ultimate enough) and headed home.

Since the ice cream was the perfect temperature when we got home – just slightly melted and soft – I got to assembling the sandwiches so I could get them into the freezer to set.

I am sure that the moms in your life will love this delicious ice cream treat after your meal on Mother’s Day! Plus, you can get the kids involved and have them assemble this easy dessert for the moms!

First Street Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich #ChooseSmart  ingredients

The Ultimate First Street Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

What You’ll Need:

  • 1 gallon of First Street Cookies & Cream ice cream
  • 1 package of First Street chocolate chip cookies
  • mini chocolate chips

What You Do:

First Street Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich #ChooseSmart  scoop onto cookie

1. Take a scoop of ice cream and set it down on the flat side of one of the cookies.

First Street Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich #ChooseSmart sandwich with another cookie

2. Place another cookie right side up on top and smush down just a bit.

First Street Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich #ChooseSmart  roll into mini chocolate chips (or sprinkles)

3. Roll sides of sandwich into chocolate chips.

First Street Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich #ChooseSmart  re-freeze before serving

4. Place sandwiches on a tray and repeat until you have as many as you need. Make sure to store in the freezer so they don’t melt.

First Street Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich #ChooseSmart  enjoy with loved ones

5. Serve to your family and enjoy!

We love how easy it is to #ChooseSmart and find all of the ingredients we need for our family’s Mother’s Day celebration all at Smart & Final!

What’s your favorite sweet treat on Mother’s Day?

Disclaimer: I am a member of the Collective Bias™ Social Fabric® Community.  This shop has been compensated as part of a social shopper insights study for Collective Bias™ and Smart & Final  #CBias #SocialFabric

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Pinterest Inspiration


  1. Yummy! And so simple! I will have to make a stop at my local Smart and Final – I love the ice cream selections offered!
    Leila recently posted…Johnson & Johnson For All You LoveMy Profile

  2. Those looks so good. Why wasn’t I invited over? lol. Those remind me of an ice cream sandwich I’d get as a kid. My mouth is watering right now. For mother’s day I enjoy homemade cake. My husband and daughter always make me one. Can’t wait for tomorrow.
    Tiffany C. recently posted…Doc McStuffins Time For Your Check-Up DVD GiveawayMy Profile

  3. This is easy enough for me to make! You know I’m an almost homemade type of mom so… I love this! I would love to eat one right now too!
    Mariah recently posted…Celebrate Mothers Day with Gift of Time #SocialBlackoutMy Profile

  4. Uh, YUM! I am totally trying this next time I go buy ice cream. I love cookies and I love ice cream. It’s the perfect treat!
    Aly Mashrah recently posted…Creamy Broccoli Pasta Salad RecipeMy Profile

  5. How fun and yummy! Happy Mother’s Day!
    Kristin Wheeler (Mama Luvs Books) recently posted…Creating Cool Movies with the Magisto AppMy Profile

  6. I really do love that recipe and thanks for sharing. My favorite sweet treat on Mother’s Day is Ice Cream. 🙂
    Quida recently posted…Mother’s Day Freebies + Other Creative IdeasMy Profile

  7. Oh wow, that looks yummy and super easy! That is just my kind of treat! Thank you for sharing. 🙂
    Jodi @ A Mom Having Fun recently posted…Preparing for a Medical Emergency – Use AFLACMy Profile

  8. My stomach is GROWLING! Those look so delicious and so easy!
    Maggie C recently posted…Get those pictures off your phone and into a GrooveBook!My Profile

  9. This is such a fun idea and simple enough for the kids to make their own. Love it!
    Angela recently posted…Encourage Moms Through Johnson’s Baby Cares ProgramMy Profile

  10. Yum, these look absolutely delicious!
    Crystal @ Simply Being recently posted…Halloween Time at the Disneyland ResortMy Profile


  1. […] Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich 5. Gluten Free Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches 6. The Ultimate Ice Cream Sandwich 7. Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches 8. Peanut Butter Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches 9. Snickerdoodle […]

Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge

© A Crafty Spoonful - All Rights Reserved
It is OK to use one of my photos provided a link back and/or proper credit is given. It is NOT ok to copy and paste a whole post including instructions. Please do not remove watermarks or alter images in any way. Please contact me with any questions at